Showing posts with label protestant. Show all posts
Showing posts with label protestant. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 6, 2013

Tradition and the Bible



When you tell your Protestant friends or relatives about the "Traditions" of the Catholic Church you're likely to receive some attention. The antithesis to a church that relies on the "Bible only" is not a church that relies on "Tradition only." That is what most objectors to Catholicism would like others to think - that we believe that Tradition somehow trumps the Scriptures. But that couldn't be further from the truth.

The Catholic Church teaches that the Bible is an authority, but not the authority. Just as the Church also teaches Tradition as an authority, but not the authority. And the Protestant must understand this and in order to make that happen effectively, the Catholic must be able to effectively communicate this.

One thing to bring up is that Protestants actually believe in Tradition more than they think. In fact, using the Bible at all is a step of faith in the Traditions of the Church. Why? Because there is no way of determining what books belong there in the first place, that is, which writings of the early Church are inspired or not. The Bible existed long before the Reformation and was trusted as "inspired" long before Luther removed certain books. Aside from that issue, the very fact that Protestants have the Bible at all is virtue of Tradition and the Authority of the Church. How else did they receive it? There is no place in the Bible itself that names which books belong there. And in addition, to assert the notion that, "we know in our hearts which books belong" as Calvin, the Geneva Reformer wrote, is the same sort of self edifying gobbledygook the Mormons use to justify their "inspired" texts.

That point has to stick in the minds of any honest reader. The celebration of Church services on Sunday is also a product of Church decisions, not Bible only teachings. If the Bible were the only source that we need to be guided to salvation, where is the unity among Protestants? The Holy Spirit is not a spirit of division! If one disagrees with a particular interpretation there is often one more division. If someone disagrees with that branch from there, another division starts. Sooner or later the religion and system is unrecognizable. One only needs to look at Lutheranism next to a modern Reformed Baptist to see the fruits of Bible only teachings. One was supposed to be the real deal, but then came along another dissident believer who saw things differently.

And here is the point: if the Catholic Church is so wrong in its authoritative structure, how come we still teach the same doctrine for close to 2000 years? That must count for something to any discerning heart.

Friday, November 1, 2013

Halloween and All Saints Day

In the Catholic Church we have obligations. We are to go to Mass each Sunday and also on certain Holy Days. Halloween itself is not a Holy Day, but it is the eve of All Saints Day in which we remember and celebrate the lives of all Saints who have left this world in faith. But Protestants are removed from that. I'll be completely honest with you, as a Protestant I grew more and more disgusted with the idea of Halloween. Ask my wife. It was to the point were I was ready to stop the celebration all together!

Of course, to a Protestant it is more than just a day of dress-up and candy. We have to give them credit, its also a day for family fun. But because Protestants do not celebrate the Holy Days as the Church has for so long its not even an issue to them. The time between now and the Reformation, circa 1530-ish has diminished almost all memory that Halloween is a serious day. For them, All Saints Day is a Catholic thing. It is interesting that they still celebrate Easter and Christmas - those aren't even "in the Bible" and few are even aware that the decision to celebrate Easter on a Sunday each year was the authoritative decision of the 11th Bishop of Rome, Pope St. Anicetus (155-165). The celebration is completely Catholic through and through. But that's just Easter. You don't want to get me started on the Catholicity of Christmas so I will digress.

Halloween is a special day now as a Catholic. It's more than candy and dress-up and the occasional scare-prank which are harmless. It's a day were we prepare to celebrate, which is just as important as the celebration itself. Why else have Advent if not to prepare our hearts for Christmas? Why else have Lent if not to prepare our hearts for Easter? The eve of All Saints Day might be only one day worth, but it gives the necessary time to prepare to say a "thank you" to those who have gone before us. It doesn't just include St. Gregory, or Thomas, or the "greats" but also our grandparents, our children who might have perished, or those whom our wives have miscarried.

This Holy Day is for all Christians, not just Catholics because the Catholic Church doesn't have a patent on making Saints. Adding to that, for the Protestant or "non-denominational" (which is still Protestant) reader, please understand that the Church sees you as our family as well. We don't share all the same beliefs but Protestants can't afford to lose out on All Saints Day. So if you don't celebrate it, give it a look. I hope that sheds a little light on this special Holy Day. Think of this as less of a day of obligation and more of a day of opportunity. A day particularly set aside for thanksgiving for our brothers and sisters who died faithfully, or even less than faithfully but still with the hope of the Savior Jesus.

Tuesday, April 2, 2013

Is It Merely Bread? A Look At The Holy Eucharist (Communion)

Is It Merely Bread? A Look At The Holy Eucharist, The Blessed Sacrament




I am unsure where to begin with this entry. Always, I make it a point to be polite, gentle, but also convincing, reasonable, and faithful to the claims of the Church. But really, I want to be helpful, eye-opening, and I want to show the world what I have discovered, but I realize with the subject that I am going to write about, it can only be a revelation from the Lord. We can discern with our reason as humans and Christians, but ultimately God will have to write this claim on your heart. But let me insert this caveat before I end that thought: just because God does not noticeably place this on your heart does not mean it is not meant for you. Ever think about that in your walk? That we use this rationale when thinking about the lost of the world, and how to them God does not exist; that doesn’t make that a fact. Facts are facts because they are unalterable; our thoughts, beliefs, and what-nots, don’t change the facts. So consider that when you read this; that even thought it might be convincing, or a nice exegetical analysis of scripture and history, and just because your emotions or in pray your don’t think you receive anything, does not mean that this is not for you – because if you get this, you will see that this is the whole summation, the whole enchilada, the very gift from God to the Church: his flesh and blood. It really will change everything for you.
What the scriptures say:
The Evangelists, AKA the Gospel authors all discuss this important topic. Now, commonly, the Gospel writers would speak of separate issues. For example, Luke, a physician, noted the many actual names for the diseases that were healed; or Matthew the tax collector kept an accurate tab on numbers such as the miraculous feedings; or Mark, which is traditionally called “the Q” is said to be co-written with the testimonial input of Peter and thus records a massive account of the Passion more than any other Gospel (don’t forget how much his denial meant afterword to Peter). So you see the Gospels are sort of written differently cause of the occasions that meant much to that writer. But in each of the Gospels, specific account is given in reference to the conversation and events that took place with the Holy Communion. I will use the account in John for this though (Chapter 6):
“25 When they found Him on the other side of the sea, they said to Him, “Rabbi, when did You get here?”
 26 Jesus answered, “I assure you: You are looking for Me, not because you saw the signs, but because you ate the loaves and were filled. 27 Don’t work for the food that perishes but for the food that lasts for eternal life, which the Son of Man will give you, because God the Father has set His seal of approval on Him.”
 28 “What can we do to perform the works of God?” they asked.
 29 Jesus replied, “This is the work of God—that you believe in the One He has sent.”
 30 “What sign then are You going to do so we may see and believe You?” they asked. “What are You going to perform? 31 Our fathers ate the manna in the wilderness, just as it is written: He gave them bread from heaven to eat.”
 32 Jesus said to them, “I assure you: Moses didn’t give you the bread from heaven, but My Father gives you the real bread from heaven. 33 For the bread of God is the One who comes down from heaven and gives life to the world.”
 34 Then they said, “Sir, give us this bread always!”
   35 “I am the bread of life,” Jesus told them. “No one who comes to Me will ever be hungry, and no one who believes in Me will ever be thirsty again. 36 But as I told you, you’ve seen Me,[i] and yet you do not believe. 37 Everyone the Father gives Me will come to Me, and the one who comes to Me I will never cast out. 38 For I have come down from heaven, not to do My will, but the will of Him who sent Me. 39 This is the will of Him who sent Me: that I should lose none of those He has given Me but should raise them up on the last day. 40 For this is the will of My Father: that everyone who sees the Son and believes in Him may have eternal life, and I will raise him up on the last day.”
 41 Therefore the Jews started complaining about Him because He said, “I am the bread that came down from heaven.” 42 They were saying, “Isn’t this Jesus the son of Joseph, whose father and mother we know? How can He now say, ‘I have come down from heaven’?”
 43 Jesus answered them, “Stop complaining among yourselves. 44 No one can come to Me unless the Father who sent Me draws him, and I will raise him up on the last day. 45 It is written in the Prophets: And they will all be taught by God. Everyone who has listened to and learned from the Father comes to Me— 46 not that anyone has seen the Father except the One who is from God. He has seen the Father.
   47 “I assure you: Anyone who believes has eternal life. 48 I am the bread of life. 49 Your fathers ate the manna in the wilderness, and they died. 50 This is the bread that comes down from heaven so that anyone may eat of it and not die. 51 I am the living bread that came down from heaven. If anyone eats of this bread he will live forever. The bread that I will give for the life of the world is My flesh.”
 52 At that, the Jews argued among themselves, “How can this man give us His flesh to eat?”
 53 So Jesus said to them, “I assure you: Unless you eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink His blood, you do not have life in yourselves. 54 Anyone who eats My flesh and drinks My blood has eternal life, and I will raise him up on the last day, 55 because My flesh is real food and My blood is real drink. 56 The one who eats My flesh and drinks My blood lives in Me, and I in him. 57 Just as the living Father sent Me and I live because of the Father, so the one who feeds on Me will live because of Me. 58 This is the bread that came down from heaven; it is not like the manna your fathers ate—and they died. The one who eats this bread will live forever.”
Above the Manna
I have done the pleasure of underlining the important phrases here in John 6 that are the focus of the study. First of all, understand how cultured the Jews were in this time. For the past 1300 years or so, Moses was their prime Patriarch, giving them the Law, the revelation of the Lord, the Promise land, and all of this through a miraculous, slow to anger God. Jesus quickly inserts his teaching that the multitudes ought not to look for mere food, but to look for the bread of heaven. Yes, Jesus was referring to himself and then seconds later declared this as a fact, not a mere metaphor (v 27 & v 35). But he makes a sharp comparison between the manna, given to the Hebrews to survive, and himself, a bread that will give eternal life. Again, first, he declares that he is above the manna in stature and nature. Ever thought of what a super claim that was? He was saying that the bread of life is more powerful, more vital for survival eternally than the manna. How can a metaphor be superior to a supernatural gift from God? He says that Moses gave them the manna, but the Lord gives a superior meal. You see plainly where Jesus says that eating the bread of life is a real act, and a real substance. That Greek word there in verse 50, “… anyone may eat of it and not die” in the Lexicon means “to consume a thing, to take food, eat a meal, to devour.” Thayer’s Lexicon says that this word literally means to chew on a substance to satisfy ones hunger and thirst. The reference gives other versions of the word for poetical use, like a metaphor, but that is not the word here that Jesus used. 
Just Plain Offensive
Let us move on. The Jews then began to argue and contemplate his words because they were offended. But… how could they be so offended by a metaphor. They were literally convinced that he meant what he said, that if they wanted to follow him any longer, they must chew on his flesh and drink his blood. Even his disciples (some of them) said it was tough teaching. But notice that Jesus never corrects that it is a mere “teaching” but that it is a requirement. Jesus was always happy and helpful in explaining his parables. But the one reference that Jesus makes that offends the entire multitude, he simply repeats his message and commands them to stop arguing – they have no rebuttal. “Unless you eat… and drink…”
I am sure at this point they are all thinking, “please clarify!” and he does. “My flesh is real food… my blood is real drink…”  The academic Greek in blood and drink are very convincing. The reader really has to pray and ask themselves why all the people would leave Jesus over a metaphor? Why would he not correct them? All he needed to say was “wait! Here is what I was really saying.” All he says is “there are some among you who don’t believe”(v 64) “will you leave me too.” (v 67) I was astonished at what I had missed in this the first million times I read it. Sort of makes you think, no?  But this is the promise, next comes the institution.
The Institution
 As a devout and defensive Protestant, I always went to the institution of the Lord Supper as a defense for the metaphorical viewpoint. I thought it was spotless. I now believe I was very wrong.  I’ll use Matthew Chapter 26 first:
“26 As they were eating, Jesus took bread, blessed and broke it, gave it to the disciples, and said, “Take and eat it; this is My body.” 27 Then He took a cup, and after giving thanks, He gave it to them and said, “Drink from it, all of you. 28 For this is My blood that establishes the covenant; it is shed for many for the forgiveness of sins. 29 But I tell you, from this moment I will not drink of this fruit of the vine until that day when I drink it in a new way in My Father’s kingdom with you.”   
Luke’s Gospel accounted the “do this in remembrance of me (Luke 22:19)”
I haven’t underlined anything because this whole paragraph is so important to the doctrine of the Eucharist and how the Church celebrates it now and always. First look at that word in verse 26, that Jesus blesses it. This is no mere thankful blessing; that one comes in the next verse. The word here actually means “to consecrate.” From this moment on, it is never referred to as bread and wine again by the utterance of Jesus. He tells them after that what in fact they are. Interesting point here that the same words he used in Johns Gospel for “eat” and “drink” are the very same Greek words. His promise was fulfilled before their very eyes.  And in Luke, “remember” is not anything other than what he says it is. I mean to say that Him (Jesus) saying this does not make it a metaphor. In fact, once again Jesus is only explicit about the contents of the wine and bread being now blood and flesh, only commanding us to remember Him when we do it. Then I consider this: Jesus says the “blood” which they are to drink is the blood that was shed for the eternal covenant. Jesus dies a real death, he bled real blood. He didn’t metaphorically die, and did not metaphorically believe, so what else what He referring to?
The Two Views
There are two views about this topic and it would not be important if it did not have a very dogmatic sounding name, right? No laughs? Okay. The first is Transubstantiation which is the belief that the real presence of Christ is present within the bread and wine under the appearance of bread and wine still. You could say: it transforms in everything besides appearance. This is a matter of “substance” over appearance. The other is Consubstantiation, which is the belief that it is still bread and wine, period. Yes these are two medieval words. As with several other doctrines, the words were given to clarify what the Church officially believes. In fact, this teaching was not questioned for 1000 years and didn’t enter into any form of Christianity for 1600 years! Much like the “Trinity,” modern words are not given until heresy presents its ugly face. Trinity was a word given to fight the Gnostics and later the Arian heresy.   
Consider this: "Substance" here means what something is in itself. A hat's shape is not the hat itself, nor is its color the hat, nor is its size, nor its softness to the touch, nor anything else about it perceptible to the senses. The hat itself (the "substance") has the shape, the color, the size, the softness and the other appearances, but is distinct from them. Whereas the appearances, which are referred to by the philosophical term accidents are perceptible to the senses, the substance is not.
Examination (what else does the Bible say?)
Are there any other references in the bible that support the Catholic doctrine? Why yes, there are, thank you so much for asking. Let me show you.
Chapter eleven of the first letter to the church at Corinth (1 Corinthians 11), Paul is quite displeased about the abuse of this sacrament, the Eucharist. ***Click this sentence to go to the chapter. *** This chapter starts out pretty scary for a Bible-only Christian when Paul mentions “you always remember me and keep the traditions just as I delivered them to you.” Now… hmmm. Paul is “delivering traditions” which means that the delivery had a starting point. He did not make this up all by himself. Anyone who makes a delivery receives it (whatever it is) and carries it and hands it off to the intended receiver. Well, that leaves an awful lot to consider. It means we have no idea what he delivered. But that Catholic Church remembers what he delivered very well, this is the application of Apostolic Succession.
Paul has a few things to get out of the way but then starts on the point in verse 17. He says that he heard that they eat in division, and they act as if the Lords Supper (he calls it this, not me) is any other event, getting drunk, and getting their stomachs full. He is upset because they eat it as if it is not the Eucharist, as if it is just bread and wine, while when they are supposed to be coming together to remember Jesus as a community in cohesion as a body! Remember Jesus’ words “when you do this remember me.” He then recounts the story (remember this is another tradition cause it was not “scripture” until 394ad). Well, it that same “eat” word again, esthio. It pays to discover. Read on about the judgment and condemnation they will receive for this unholy act.
“27 So then, whoever eats the bread or drinks the cup of the Lord in an unworthy manner will be guilty of sinning against the body and blood of the Lord. 28 Everyone ought to examine themselves before they eat of the bread and drink from the cup. 29 For those who eat and drink without discerning the body of Christ eat and drink judgment on themselves. 30 That is why many among you are weak and sick, and a number of you have fallen asleep. 31 But if we were more discerning with regard to ourselves, we would not come under such judgment. 32 Nevertheless, when we are judged in this way by the Lord, we are being disciplined so that we will not be finally condemned with the world” (NIV).
I cannot see how if we are condemned for “not discerning the body of Christ”, it can’t just be a mere metaphor. Is there any other example you can think of where God condemns us for not believing a metaphor? I cannot think of one. Use your reason; the authors intent is much more serious than metaphor.  
Paul consecrates the bread in Acts 27:35. The actual Greek word used in Acts is eucharisteō. What word does that appear to look like? It is the Eucharist. Its biblical proof that, so far as the objector is concerned, the word exists in the bible.  

It really is an important issue, too. Do not convince yourself that this is another rag bag spine issue that we don’t have to really understand. This is one of the things that we find in every Gospel account. Jesus said to us that “you do not have life in you” and Paul tells us that if we do not discern His body when we take it, that we are damned and condemned. Even more so, Paul told us that we must reflect deeply as to not accept it unworthily. I was too offended when I was “trying out” or “checking out” Catholic Mass and I was instructed not to take it. I was thinking “but I am a Christian! Half these people in this room aren’t as devout as me.” But they were right, and I was arrogant.
A Possible Conclusion
The straightforward name of this sacrament is “Communion.” Well if it is a metaphor, what are you in communion with? Nothing. This is a difficult teaching, the disciples were right. But Jesus made a way for us to literally be at one with Him while on Earth. He made possible what we don’t see as possible or probable. Will we believe that one chapter before his promise of this, that he made a few loafs into many, but cannot believe this? Will we believe that at Cana he turned water into wine, but cannot accept that he can turn wine into blood? So why don’t we believe it? I think there are three reasons: 1) we don’t want to believe it, it offends us, 2) we don’t think we need to believe it, or 3) we don’t think God is actually asking us to drink blood and eat flesh. If yours is #1, the consequences, let me remind you are grave. If yours is #2, again, how can you be condemned for a metaphor? And #3, God made it how He wants it to be, and be thankful that it didn’t actually turn into blood or meat, God is so merciful! If you have a reason other than this, like you’re not convinced, okay, but keep reading on the subject I urge you. All of the evidence isn’t even here, there is much more to be said and discovered.
I want you the reader to consider the following. I have laid out some common evidence that many consider extremely convincing. If it is or it isn’t for you, either way, consider this: if it isn’t true, no big deal, but if it really is Jesus, don’t you want some?! Wouldn’t you want to take Him in every day? And if it is true, you should really consider the rest of what Catholics teach. This is the one part of Catholicism that either pulls people in or bounces them away.

History is the greatest demonstration of evidence. All Christians believe that "truth is truth" and is not subject to change. If that's so, then why the change in the 16th century for Protestants? There is not teaching contrary to that of Catholicism before this time. So I ask again, why the change? If it was truth once, it is always truth.

I really hoped you enjoyed this. Comment if you have a question, a thought, or a rebuttal.

Wednesday, June 27, 2012

Apostles and Nicene Creeds Part 3

Where did we leave off? Oh yeah… I should have added “born of the Virgin Mary” to the Apostles creed.  But I digress and continue where I left off last:
Apostles: “… suffered under Pontius Pilate, was crucified, died, and was buried; he descended to the dead. On the third day he rose again; in accordance with the scriptures.”
Nicene: “For our sake he was crucified under Pontius Pilate; he suffered death and was buried. On the third day he rose again, in accordance with the scriptures.”
                It’s not hard to see the progression of the understanding of the faith, and the detail that was later poured into the new (Nicene) creed.  We observe the mention of Pontius Pilate, but why? What does Pilate have to do with our profession of faith? Should the Church Fathers have included only points about God, Jesus, and the Resurrection? It’s hard to say. What we submit though, is that Pilate was an instrument of God (just as Pharaoh was), and so where the Jews who turned him over. The Bible actually reads pretty chillingly that God opened salvation to the Gentiles because the Jews did not believe, and to make them jealous (Rom 11:11); I think we rarely consider this. It’s really another mystery of Gods work.  The point of Pontius Pilate being mentioned though is to properly give historical accuracy to the death of Jesus – because that’s what this portion of the Creed is about – how and when he died.
                Some would say he died a unique death. I disagree and so does history. Many at his time were *reportedly* creating signs, and making claims, and killed for it – but Jesus’ ministry was different, and his claims were as well.  In fact, in Acts we read that the high priest Caiaphas warns everybody to beware the Christians because they simply ‘aren’t going away’ as the followers of the other potential messiahs did. That’s pretty crazy if you ask me! To preserve history (since scripture in the New Testament had not yet been canonized) it was necessary to include this to show precisely the point in time that Jesus was killed. There is no mistake about the mentioning of the Roman Prelate in his death. Notice that the translation is “suffered under” and not “suffered at the hands of” or “killed by” – it was under the reign of Pontius Pilate who became a notable figure in other means as well in Roman history. It is a distinct reference to the time and place that Jesus suffered his passion.
                The next interesting part is “in accordance with the scriptures.” Now, I get the feeling that many Protestants are vaguely familiar with the creeds in either form. Catholics read the Nicene at Mass and should be somewhat familiar with it – but I wonder how many trip over this part about the “scriptures” or just read right through it. Has the reader of this blog considered which scriptures the creeds are referring to? First off, it should be recognized that the reference is found not only in the creed but in St. Paul’s first letter to the Corinthians: “For I delivered to you as of first importance what I also received, that Christ died for our sins, in accordance with the scriptures, that he was buried, that he was raised on the third day, in accordance with the scriptures” (15:3-4). Twice Paul refers to the scriptures. It cannot be any more evident that Paul was referring to the Old Testament just as the creeds are.  We might recognize the story and see the connection with “scriptures” as the NT, but remember, the creeds, both of them, are older than the canonized Bible – the Nicene by almost 80 years.    
With Paul saying this and it being then inserted in the creeds it is the equivalent of saying “in order to fulfill the prophecy about his life, death, and resurrection.” His virgin birth in Isaiah 7:14, His (God’s) son in Isaiah 9:6-7, his death for us in Isaiah 49:6 and 42:1-4, suffering foretold in Isaiah 53:3, rejected by rulers in Psalm 118:22, betrayed by 30 pieces of silver in Zachariah 11:12, and many more. The creed is vital to our Faith. It’s like a mini-new testament – before the New Testament was even new or a testament at all.  

Thursday, January 5, 2012

The Largest Pillar to Fall

A devout protestant argues for months, becomes Catholic. Oh Lordie, there is so much to tell. and here is the first:

The Largest Pillar to Fall
Martin Luther said, “Justification is the article on which the Church stands or falls.”
                If the reader of this knows anything about the reformation, he/she should know that Luther was not the whole reformation, but got a serious ball rolling for others. So I will often refer back to Luther, and you might say “but I don’t like or agree with Luther.” That doesn’t matter. What matters first is why the reformation happened at all. Bear this in mind.               
                Before Luther, there were many reformers. Most of these reformers wanted a moral reformation – a challenge to a 700 year problem for corrupt positions in the Church, including the Pope.  Luther was a solid advocate of a reformation against the corruptions of the Holy Catholic Church. In his well heard of “95 Theses” there were several issues Luther addressed boldly.  Ever read them? They are available online these days. Have a look. You will see him pointing out three recurring problems: 1) the power of a Pope, 2) the corruption of the church, 3) the issue of indulgences.  Indulgences were the chief issue, but I see three common topics. Either way, these were the mainstream issues he spoke out against in the beginning of his ministry. Even during this time, Luther often was heard speaking that there was no single issue that should cause him to break free from Rome (the Roman Catholic Church). Bear in mind he was no layman, he was indeed a devout monk turned priest ordained and anointed. He wanted the unity of the Church to remain integral in whatever happened. But, his invocation as the Diet of Worms “here I stand,” and the “article on which the Church stands or falls” are central to the reformation.  Why the change of heart? He was probably angry as the years went by. Trying to have someone kidnapped, misleading them to a castle tower, and other things might do that…
                So what was the position on justification exactly? Luther’s view was Justification by “Faith Alone.” In the Latin it is “Sola Fide.” To fill the reader in, the Catholic view of Justification is and has always been ‘Faith + Works.’ To me, as a protestant at the time, this didn’t seem too foolish. Of course salvation was from Faith alone!  I recall to my mind what St. Paul says in Romans 3, about not boasting of works, because it has nothing to do with salvation. When Luther was challenged by scripture such as James 2:24, “you see that a man is justified by works and not faith alone.” Luther responded by calling the Book of James “an Epistle of Straw,” inciting it should be burned. Well there is a serious contention there between Paul and James, right? Does Paul not also say in Galatians 5:6, “what is important is faith expressing itself in love.” Does James not echo this saying, “faith without works is dead” (James 2:27). You can check out the Greek if you please about what I am saying but the best thing to do is take into context the scripture here. Paul, when he says works have nothing to do with salvation was speaking of works of the law, and later is referring to charitable works. Well, hey, so is James. James also is referring to obedience to God in the works.
                Any plain reader can see that the Catholic view is clearly derived explicitly from scripture. This is rare. I will write about it another time, but the doctrines of Christianity are very rarely explicit from the Scriptures; rather they are very implicit. It was only with new heresies that the Church saw the need to define, dogmatize, or opinionate the Churches official position. A perfect example is the Trinity. For now, just know, or learn to see that the primary reason Luther gave us for the Schism is completely unbiblical itself. Heavens knows how this actually took off as an academic apology for Christendom, but I can see where people wanted away from the corruptions of the Church. What’s terrible is that the reason for this break, “faith alone” is found nowhere in the Bible. But, don’t rush into the judgment. Catholics do not count faith as important as works, or vice versa. Any Deacon, Priest, Bishop, or Pope will tell you that the faith-filled relationship is the utmost important! It is a huge misunderstanding that the Catholic Church weighs so heavily on works.
                So I have pretty simply laid it out for the reader. You can do as I did, and check out the debates on youtube, or the ones in text. They are all over the Internet. You will see that neither back down, but I think it is easily discernible that the Catholic tradition of “faith and works” for justification is a better argument, and is biblical as well. And that brings up a big point on the benefit of the Catholic view. They have +2000 years of this belief in faith and works. It is no modern opinion, or a response to Luther, or anything else; it was echoed throughout the ages from the very beginning. This is so important as you will hear many these days say, “well, the Catholic Church does not look like the New Testament Church we observe in scripture.” Point taken. But according to whom? This can drag out a whole separate issue, but really, if we look at scripture only, and ignore traditions, we wind up in a very harmful spot. I know, I will be blasted for that, but I will explain the scripture and tradition thing another day. Stick with me for now.
If you followed along, you saw where in scripture we observe faith and works and not just faith alone. Paul said, “do not get into vein arguments.” Some would call this a stupid argument, “they both teach the same thing.” Well, yes, Protestant pastors will teach that faith without works is dead faith, but will not include works in justification. Whatever the case, if it is such a silly topic then that should certainly create some doubt in your mind for Luther’s and the other reformers (who all agreed, by the way, with Luther) reason for starting the reformation and deciding that a schism with the Church was more important.
That is the greatest pillar to fall for my foundation for Protestantism. I was not the first or the last, but after I realized that Luther was not in sync with the historical church, all of Protestantism began to make much less sense, and was much less necessary, and much less truthful.  So don’t get me wrong, Protestant churches are great, and they preach, mostly, the Truth, but it is not the whole truth. In fact, there is only one Church that says it is infallible.


Please write me with questions: shaunmc04@gmail.com